How did our four columnists do? Here are their first ten picks in the 2019 NFL Draft.
All four columnists got the first two picks right. They all missed on the #3 and #4 picks, but three of four picked Devin White at #5. From there it was mostly misses. The lone exception was Gutierrez getting the #10 pick (Bush) right. The big misses of the night were Clelin Ferrell and Doug Jones as Top Ten picks (#4 and #6, respectively).
Overall, Mike Gutierrez correctly guessed on 40% of the picks in the order that they were selected. In terms of correct picks, irrespective of order, Platania finished at 60%, Gutierrez at 70%, Stanchina at 60%, and Feirman at 50%
Our overall winner, Mike Gutierrez.
| ACTUAL | Platania | Gutierrez | Stanchina | Feirman |
| Murray | √ | √ | √ | √ |
| Bosa | √ | √ | √ | √ |
| Q Williams | Allen | Allen | Allen | Allen |
| Ferrell | Q. Williams | Q. Williams | Q. Williams | Q. Williams |
| White | √ | √ | √ | Gary |
| Jones | Haskins | Haskins | Oliver | J. Williams |
| Allen | Taylor | Hockenson | Taylor | Metcalf |
| Hockenson | Sweat | Sweat | Gary | Brown |
| Oliver | Hockinson | Fant | J. Williams | Hockinson |
| Bush | Lock | √ | Lock | J. Williams |
